• News
  • Culture

Is Hindu law not discriminatory?

Is Hindu law not discriminatory?

"If I have faith that Lord Ram was born in Ayodhya, then it is a matter of faith and there is no question of constitutional morality".

When the bench asked how a Muslim man would seek divorce if the triple talaq was outlawed, Rohatgi said: "The Centre will bring out a law. It is better that the bench deals with all three", the AG said.

"The scope of reference had all the three issues, that is divorce, nikah halala, polygamy".

Muslim women in India have demanded a ban to triple talaq with several women petitioning the nation's top court, the Supreme Court, to overturn the practice.

"It will be hazardous for the Court to interpret it in six days of hearing", Sibal said.

Rohatgi's submission came when the court asked him about the remedies for a Muslim man to end a marriage if such practices were struck down.

Supporting the position of closure the act of triple talaq, the Allahabad High Court had before declared that the privileges of any individual, including Muslim ladies, can't be damaged for the sake of "individual law".

Till then, it seemed to have gone perfectly for the Congress leader and senior lawyer appearing for the All India Muslim Personal Law Board in the top court.

He had said triple talaq was a discrimination on the ground of sex and this practice was abhorrent to the tenets of holy Quran and no amount of advocacy can save this "sinful" practice which is contrary to constitutional tenets.

More news: Italian Open win allows Sharapova to qualify for Wimbledon

Referring to the prevalent practice in Islamic nations, he had said even if one says talaq thrice in a go, it was considered as one, thus negating irrevocability of divorce.

"The Central Government makes rules but in my opinion the apex court should not interfere into it", Sibal said. "Is it a question to be decided on constitutional morality...but when it comes to triple talaq, the question of constitutional morality is raised". Triple talaq is contrary to equality, gender equality and human rights. Immediately after a few years of the death of Prophet Muhammad, the companions of Prophet Muhammad talked about triple talaq.

A five-judge constitution bench, headed by Chief Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar, started hearing arguments on the constitutional validity of the practice of "instant triple talaq" or talaq-e-bidat on Friday.

However, the All India Muslim Personal Law Board has opposed any judicial interference in what it calls a religious matter, protected under Article 25, which grants freedom of religion.

To this, the bench insisted that the government has to first prove that this practice of triple talaq was not essential to Islam and only then can it delve further into other aspects.

If tfaith of Hindus about Ram's birth can not be questioned then triple talaq is a matter of faith for Muslims.

To this, the bench had said, "we can not do that".

"No, never", Sibal added when the bench asked whether a private member's bill had ever been moved on the subject.

Leave Your Comment

Leave Your Comment


Latest News

  • Mexican journalist shot dead in Sinaloa state

    Ricardo Sanchez Perez del Pozo, a lawyer with a background in worldwide law and human rights, took over the post. In a previous interview with NBC News, the slain journalist was asked why he didn't seek asylum in the U.S.
    LaVar Ball attacks Fox Sports reporter in sexist rant

    LaVar Ball attacks Fox Sports reporter in sexist rant

    Leahy wasn't the only person Ball set his sights on on Wednesday. "Yeah, if you have a women's company". The entire exchange began when Leahy asked how many pairs of Lonzo Ball's $495 shoes he had sold.

    China's Xi appeals to foreign leaders for freer trade

    The strategy includes two key areas of development such as economic belt of the Silk Road and the Sea Silk Road. He, however, did not give a time frame for the new loans, aid and funding pledged on Sunday.
  • Rolf Harris to be freed from jail tomorrow

    Rolf Harris to be freed from jail tomorrow

    His release from prison means he will now be able to attend the court in person, while on bail, for the remainder of the trial. Harris denies four charges of indecent assault. "She said she had been groped by Rolf in a taxi", he told the court.

    Mourinho: Manchester United lack strength in depth to fight in two competitions

    The duo could also have their bans extended when their cases are heard by the UEFA Control, Ethics and Disciplinary Body on July 20.

    Arsene Wenger refuses to criticise West Ham over performance against Liverpool

    Getting 75 points would be four more points than a year ago . "Do it better during the season and you will not have this problem". You had basically two leagues, with the top six and everyone else", via the Mirror . "We let ourselves down really".
  • Emmanuel Macron names Edouard Philippe as French prime minister

    He said he will implement a reform agenda at home "not because Europe requests it, but because France needs it". Philippe is the mayor of the Normandy port of Le Havre, a trained lawyer and an author of political thrillers.
    Tehran mayor Qalibaf quits presidential race

    Tehran mayor Qalibaf quits presidential race

    His close association with the Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei would attract the support of conservatives across Iran. He is now facing five rivals, but some could withdraw in favor of more prominent candidates.
    Samsung Galaxy J3 (2017) now available at AT&T for $180

    Samsung Galaxy J3 (2017) now available at AT&T for $180

    The new Note 7R will be sold in four different color options - Blue Coral, Black, White, and Silver. The phone will also feature a 13MP front-facing camera.
  • Google I/O 2017: What to expect from the developer conference

    Google I/O 2017: What to expect from the developer conference

    We're also anticipating the announcement of new features for the Google Assistant AI and in turn the Google Home smart speaker. It's at this event a year ago when the company introduced Google Assistant, Google Duo, Google Allo, and Google Home.
    Amazon refreshes lineup of low-cost tablets, new kids model

    Amazon refreshes lineup of low-cost tablets, new kids model

    It can access more than 7,000 channels, apps, and Alexa skills and live TV broadcasts when used with a separate HD antenna . Amazon is taking pre-orders on a new Element 4k LED TV that comes with an integrated Fire TV platform.
    How to watch HTC U live stream

    How to watch HTC U live stream

    The Taiwanese smartphone giant is holding a live event on Tuesday where the new flagship device is expected to be revealed. Just after the CES 2017, HTC unveiled the new U series smartphones with the glossy finish body and premium price tag.
  • U.K. Minor Parties Slam 'Extreme' Brexit in Debate May Avoided

    U.K. Minor Parties Slam 'Extreme' Brexit in Debate May Avoided

    However the debate on ITV didn't feature Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn - who both refused to attend. In Paul Nuttall's head, we're all Natalie. . "I trust the people".
    Braun Strowman could be out six months after elbow surgery

    Braun Strowman could be out six months after elbow surgery

    Seth Rollins , Samoa Joe, Finn Balor , Bray Wyatt and Roman Reigns will square off on June 4, live on Sky Sports Box Office . Since WWE re-split its roster into Raw and Smackdown brands last summer, perhaps no image ha...
    Hostages freed from mosque in Central African Republic

    Hostages freed from mosque in Central African Republic

    Doctors Without Borders said at least 21 people were wounded but access to the area is needed to determine the full toll. Preliminary information reported that displaced civilians sought refuge at a mosque, a Catholic church and a hospital.
  • Dayton signs Real ID bill, averting travel woes for 2018

    Dayton signs Real ID bill, averting travel woes for 2018

    The DFL governor and GOP lawmakers traded budget offers throughout the day, as next Monday's deadline to finish their work loomed. The new law would require the Minnesota Department of Public Safety to begin issuing licenses by October 1, 2018.
    Ford using first over-the-air software updates to its 2016 cars

    Ford using first over-the-air software updates to its 2016 cars

    This should pretty exciting news for Ford owners who now won't need to buy a brand new auto to get a major infotainment upgrade. Apple CarPlay is compatible with iPhone 5 or later models running at least iOS 7.1.

    Americans Support Impeaching Donald Trump More Than They Oppose It, Poll Finds

    Just 43 percent of voters thought Trump would finish out the four-year term as president, while 45 percent thought he wouldn't. Green, who previewed his call with a tweet earlier, said it was the House of Representative's "duty" to take up impeachment.

Breaking News



Recommended

Miguel Cabrera Out 2-3 Days with Oblique Injury

Bucknor ruled he swung at the final pitch. "I don't have any mixed feelings about that game", Orioles manager Buck Showalter said. Pinch hitter Guillermo Heredia singled home the winning run with two outs in the ninth inning as Seattle defeated Chicago.

Actress Reema was most cheerful person on sets: Rajeev Verma

One of her most successful roles was in " Hum Aapke Hai Koun ...!", where she played Anupam Kher's wife and Madhuri's mother. Lagoo's son-in-law Vinay Waikul told PTI, "She was complaining of chest pain so we took her to the hospital at around 1 AM".

This Peek at Life of Kylie Teases Revelations About the Controversial Celeb

According to reports, even though she just ended her three year romance with Tyga , Kylie and Travis are already hot and heavy. They pointed out that they do not really know how their sister spends her days, so they will join everyone else as viewers.

First look of Aishwarya Rai at Cannes 2017

With her tresses left open, she looked exquisite as she exuded confidence and elan in her one-shoulder floor-sweeping dress. The maxi dress has a plunging neckline, the attire cinches at the waist, giving her a handsome silhouette.

Cabinet To Be Briefed On Cyber Attack Fallout

It is understood that hospitals in the Midlands, including Portlaoise, have been the targets of previous ransomware viruses. The threat involved around 20 machines that were isolated and disinfected yesterday.

The Draft Lottery results may have killed any Jimmy Butler trade

Despite statistically getting the most likely outcome, Tuesday night was not a good night for the Phoenix Suns and their fans. The Philadelphia 76ers have done a terrific job of positioning themselves the right way for success in the lottery.

Spicer confirms Western Wall 'clearly in Jerusalem'

Friedman arrived Monday and immediately visited the Western Wall, praying there and kissing the sacred site. He said the topic would be discussed between Trump and his counterparts during next week's trip.

Tillerson Says Russia Meddled In US Election, No 'Clean Slate' With Moscow

Afterward few said any new information emerged about the increasingly tense United States standoff with Pyongyang. The best way to promote American values, Tillerson maintained, is to achieve U.S.

Hyundai, Kia Recall Moves Forward

The latest recall comes after the two firms offered to fix 1.5m cars in South Korea and the USA over possible engine stalling. Hyundai and Kia have been criticized for the lackadaisical way in which they have dealt with questions about product quality.

Cassia voters vote out incumbent school board members

Four candidates are seeking three seats on the Board of Education with the top three vote-getters each securing a three-year term. The second phase of a long-term plan to renovate and upgrade district schools will turn the attention to elementary schools.